Medicare for All – possible but not easy!

I have spent a few hours investigating the practicality of “Medicare for All” using AI to help with the analysis.  I’ve concluded that it is possible to achieve a single payer system approach, but it is expensive. It is really about what our priorities are as a nation. The merits of a Medicare for All solution in terms of changing who we are and how we take care of each other I believe undeniable. However, we have to have a plan that is workable and covers the cost. The Bernie Sander’s plan although attractive to low wage earners comes away with a huge deficit to the cost of the plan. The unfunded portion would require borrowing. We already have a $40 Trillion deficit. We can do better.  All analysis herein is against a 10 year plan for a Medicare for All that would cost $47 Trillion per worst case analysis.  The moderate case funding requirement is around $31T, but I’ve been working on the worst case scenario.

I’ve worked on a multi-source funding plan and tax strategy that features the following elements:

  • 100% of the Worst Case Projected costs covered
  • Conversion of Health Cost savings by Private Industry to a Medicare tax
  • A Value-Added-Tax of 3% 
  • A progressive all income tax replacing the Medicare tax
  • A $20,000 income exemption (married couples)
  • A roll back of ICE funding to 2023 levels 
  • A 10% reduction in Defense spending (this is always a challenge – but if we stay out of foreign war adventures we should be able to find a way forward)

A Fully Funded Medicare-for-All Plan: Executive Brief

While Senator Bernie Sanders’s Medicare-for-All financing menu prioritizes low middle-class tax rates, independent budget analysts note that it raises only ~$16.2 trillion over 10 years—leaving a $14 trillion to $31 trillion funding shortfall that would require massive deficit borrowing or deep cuts to other federal programs. By contrast, this Balanced Multi-Source Strategy pays for 100% of even the worst-case $47.0 trillion 10-year healthcare projection (2027–2036) upfront while keeping individual tax rates moderate and economically sustainable.

1. The 10-Year Funding Architecture ($47.0 Trillion Balanced)

Rather than relying on steep top-bracket income hikes or leaving multi-trillion-dollar deficits, this plan diversifies funding across six targeted streams:

  • Employer Healthcare Recapture ($11.00T): Replaces businesses’ eliminated private insurance obligations dollar for dollar, avoiding both a corporate windfall and a net tax hike on the business sector.
  • Medicaid & Public-Employee Consolidation ($8.50T): Transfers existing state Medicaid contributions and administrative savings ($4.50T) alongside federal, state, and local government employee health plan outlays ($4.00T) into one unified national risk pool.
  • Preventive Care & Avoided ER Savings ($1.50T): Captures net long-term savings from eliminating cost barriers to primary care, reducing expensive emergency room visits and acute hospitalizations.
  • Targeted Federal Spending Reductions ($1.12T): Cuts Defense spending by 10% ($1.00T on the CBO baseline) and rolls Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) funding back to FY2023 levels ($0.12T).
  • 3% National Value-Added Tax ($2.04T): Implements a broad-based, border-adjusted 3% consumption tax that boosts export competitiveness and avoids taxing business investment.
  • Flatter All-Income Tax ($22.84T): Replaces the current 1.45%–2.35% employee Medicare payroll tax with a progressive tax across all personal income (wages, business income, dividends, and realized capital gains) above a $20,000 married exemption ($10,000 single): 8.5% (20K–100K), 12.0% (100K–300K), and 15.5% (over $300K).

2. Net Household Impact vs. Current System

To measure true net spendable income (cash remaining after federal income taxes, payroll taxes, the 3% VAT, and private healthcare premiums/out-of-pocket costs), the table below compares married households under this final 8.5% / 12.0% / 15.5% + 3% VAT plan against the 2026 baseline (note: charts are omitted as Google Docs imports text and tables):

Married Household Income Current Net Spendable Income Final Flatter Plan Net Spendable Income Annual Net Change ($) Annual Net Change (%)
$20,000 $17,970 $18,304 +$334 +1.9%
$40,000 $33,660 $34,176 +$516 +1.5%
$80,000 $58,140 $63,212 +$5,072 +8.7%
$150,000 $112,685 $110,280 –$2,405 –2.1%
$300,000 $223,793 $204,693 –$19,100 –8.5%
$600,000 $429,943 $369,233 –$60,710 –14.1%
$1,000,000 $676,561 $560,851 –$115,710 –17.1%
  • Middle-Class Sweet Spot ($80,000): Families around $80,000 gain +$5,072/year in spendable cash, because eliminating ~$10,500 in family premiums/deductibles and $1,160 in existing Medicare payroll taxes outweighs their 5,100incomesurtaxand~1,488 in checkout VAT.
  • Break-Even Threshold (~$136,000): Every married household earning below roughly $136,000 comes out ahead financially; at $150,000, a family sees a modest –$2,405/year (–2.1%) net change in exchange for zero-deductible coverage.

3. Key Advantages Over Senator Sanders’s Plan

  • Zero Deficit Borrowing: Sanders’s proposal leaves up to $3.1 trillion per year unfunded; this plan balances the ledger completely, protecting Social Security, education, and infrastructure from emergency budget cuts.
  • Protects Working & Middle-Class Families: Repealing existing employee Medicare payroll taxes and eliminating private premiums and deductibles leaves households earning under ~$136,000 with higher net take-home pay even after the 3% VAT.
  • Preserves Economic Growth & Capital Formation: Sanders’s menu pushes top marginal ordinary and capital gains rates above 50%–60%, risking severe investment lock-in. Capping the top individual rate at 15.5% keeps combined federal capital gains rates under 40% (39.3%), while the 3% VAT is rebated on U.S. exports and leaves business capital investment untaxed.
  • Fair Business Transition: Whereas Sanders’s 7.5% payroll tax gives large corporations a 5T–7T windfall, recapturing the full $11 trillion in eliminated private premiums keeps aggregate business obligations neutral.

This is complicated I know, but that is the point. If we want these type of changes we need serious people working hard on such policy plans and we as a voting public need to pay attention.  Just planting a medicare for all flag is not nearly enough.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *