Medicare for All – possible but not easy!

I have spent a few hours investigating the practicality of “Medicare for All” using AI to help with the analysis.  I’ve concluded that it is possible to achieve a single payer system approach, but it is expensive. It is really about what our priorities are as a nation. The merits of a Medicare for All solution in terms of changing who we are and how we take care of each other I believe undeniable. However, we have to have a plan that is workable and covers the cost. The Bernie Sander’s plan although attractive to low wage earners comes away with a huge deficit to the cost of the plan. The unfunded portion would require borrowing. We already have a $40 Trillion deficit. We can do better.  All analysis herein is against a 10 year plan for a Medicare for All that would cost $47 Trillion per worst case analysis.  The moderate case funding requirement is around $31T, but I’ve been working on the worst case scenario.

I’ve worked on a multi-source funding plan and tax strategy that features the following elements:

  • 100% of the Worst Case Projected costs covered
  • Conversion of Health Cost savings by Private Industry to a Medicare tax
  • A Value-Added-Tax of 3% 
  • A progressive all income tax replacing the Medicare tax
  • A $20,000 income exemption (married couples)
  • A roll back of ICE funding to 2023 levels 
  • A 10% reduction in Defense spending (this is always a challenge – but if we stay out of foreign war adventures we should be able to find a way forward)

A Fully Funded Medicare-for-All Plan: Executive Brief

While Senator Bernie Sanders’s Medicare-for-All financing menu prioritizes low middle-class tax rates, independent budget analysts note that it raises only ~$16.2 trillion over 10 years—leaving a $14 trillion to $31 trillion funding shortfall that would require massive deficit borrowing or deep cuts to other federal programs. By contrast, this Balanced Multi-Source Strategy pays for 100% of even the worst-case $47.0 trillion 10-year healthcare projection (2027–2036) upfront while keeping individual tax rates moderate and economically sustainable.

1. The 10-Year Funding Architecture ($47.0 Trillion Balanced)

Rather than relying on steep top-bracket income hikes or leaving multi-trillion-dollar deficits, this plan diversifies funding across six targeted streams:

  • Employer Healthcare Recapture ($11.00T): Replaces businesses’ eliminated private insurance obligations dollar for dollar, avoiding both a corporate windfall and a net tax hike on the business sector.
  • Medicaid & Public-Employee Consolidation ($8.50T): Transfers existing state Medicaid contributions and administrative savings ($4.50T) alongside federal, state, and local government employee health plan outlays ($4.00T) into one unified national risk pool.
  • Preventive Care & Avoided ER Savings ($1.50T): Captures net long-term savings from eliminating cost barriers to primary care, reducing expensive emergency room visits and acute hospitalizations.
  • Targeted Federal Spending Reductions ($1.12T): Cuts Defense spending by 10% ($1.00T on the CBO baseline) and rolls Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) funding back to FY2023 levels ($0.12T).
  • 3% National Value-Added Tax ($2.04T): Implements a broad-based, border-adjusted 3% consumption tax that boosts export competitiveness and avoids taxing business investment.
  • Flatter All-Income Tax ($22.84T): Replaces the current 1.45%–2.35% employee Medicare payroll tax with a progressive tax across all personal income (wages, business income, dividends, and realized capital gains) above a $20,000 married exemption ($10,000 single): 8.5% (20K–100K), 12.0% (100K–300K), and 15.5% (over $300K).

2. Net Household Impact vs. Current System

To measure true net spendable income (cash remaining after federal income taxes, payroll taxes, the 3% VAT, and private healthcare premiums/out-of-pocket costs), the table below compares married households under this final 8.5% / 12.0% / 15.5% + 3% VAT plan against the 2026 baseline (note: charts are omitted as Google Docs imports text and tables):

Married Household Income Current Net Spendable Income Final Flatter Plan Net Spendable Income Annual Net Change ($) Annual Net Change (%)
$20,000 $17,970 $18,304 +$334 +1.9%
$40,000 $33,660 $34,176 +$516 +1.5%
$80,000 $58,140 $63,212 +$5,072 +8.7%
$150,000 $112,685 $110,280 –$2,405 –2.1%
$300,000 $223,793 $204,693 –$19,100 –8.5%
$600,000 $429,943 $369,233 –$60,710 –14.1%
$1,000,000 $676,561 $560,851 –$115,710 –17.1%
  • Middle-Class Sweet Spot ($80,000): Families around $80,000 gain +$5,072/year in spendable cash, because eliminating ~$10,500 in family premiums/deductibles and $1,160 in existing Medicare payroll taxes outweighs their 5,100incomesurtaxand~1,488 in checkout VAT.
  • Break-Even Threshold (~$136,000): Every married household earning below roughly $136,000 comes out ahead financially; at $150,000, a family sees a modest –$2,405/year (–2.1%) net change in exchange for zero-deductible coverage.

3. Key Advantages Over Senator Sanders’s Plan

  • Zero Deficit Borrowing: Sanders’s proposal leaves up to $3.1 trillion per year unfunded; this plan balances the ledger completely, protecting Social Security, education, and infrastructure from emergency budget cuts.
  • Protects Working & Middle-Class Families: Repealing existing employee Medicare payroll taxes and eliminating private premiums and deductibles leaves households earning under ~$136,000 with higher net take-home pay even after the 3% VAT.
  • Preserves Economic Growth & Capital Formation: Sanders’s menu pushes top marginal ordinary and capital gains rates above 50%–60%, risking severe investment lock-in. Capping the top individual rate at 15.5% keeps combined federal capital gains rates under 40% (39.3%), while the 3% VAT is rebated on U.S. exports and leaves business capital investment untaxed.
  • Fair Business Transition: Whereas Sanders’s 7.5% payroll tax gives large corporations a 5T–7T windfall, recapturing the full $11 trillion in eliminated private premiums keeps aggregate business obligations neutral.

This is complicated I know, but that is the point. If we want these type of changes we need serious people working hard on such policy plans and we as a voting public need to pay attention.  Just planting a medicare for all flag is not nearly enough.

 

Go Blue!

When your team loses
a game they should’ve won
the anguish felt is the woe
of milk that spoiled just
as you were to drink.

When your team loses
again and again and they
don’t look like they ever
expected to win, it is as if
you’ve never known milk.

There is no feeling of  loss,
there is no longer bad taste
it just simply isn’t there
and this is when apathy
becomes a friend.

For with apathy as a friend all
expectations disappear,
all excitement is muted and
together you remember better times
when you knew victory.

You long for the milk and
honey of those better days
and you hope for their return,
but you know it is beyond
the horizon, beyond what you can see.

But we believe because we
must, that they will be back
on top someday in future,
and they will play the
Victor’s song once again.

When that happens we’ll
sing Hail Hail once again
and fill our lungs with fresh
air of victory in the land
of milk and honey.

Until then we will console
with memories of past
greatness and we still
exclaim to each other
Go Blue!

My Noles friends and Gator friends know of such woes too 😉

 

 

Blue Tsunami

A much needed blue tsunami
visited our mean red shores
and washed away the latest
and greatest form of corruption
in a complete rejection of Trumpism.

The American people are stupid
but not terminally so.
They elected him and protected
his cronies not once but twice.
But no this is not what we want.

But the Dems should not celebrate
and believe their win was anything but
a rejection of Trump and his enablers…
but they will… they’ll see it as a mandate
for their own crazy.

Yes Americans can be stupid but not terminally so.

Hopefully something is learned from the last ten years, and we’ll find ourselves in a era of cooperative government and meaningful improvements for everyone, even those who were ‘otherized’ over the last decade.

 

 

Time

We throw back time like we own it, like
we are masters of our world.
But we are just stewards of this point,
this place we call home and think it ours.

For are we not breathing the air breathed before?
Is not the light of stars been seen a billion years
before and does it not carry with it all those who came
before their memories and dreams and more?

We think thoughts, like it cannot last much longer
when we experience today’s conflict and pain,
and yet it does, and will be some memory of
the past, as it is repeated again and again.

Everything changes and everything remains the same.
For there is no original thought, no original greed
there is no original sin that didn’t come from within
our history and our millions of years of making our way.

And yet, there is also the love of couples and families
and children raised with hope they will have better
than we, and the hope and prayer that we’ll see some
more of all that is good, all that we are capable of.

Yes, such a conundrum, for we are both good and bad,
destructive and constructive, and somehow we survive,
somehow we populate all corners of this pinpoint space
of existence, and explore beyond, as we’ve learned to thrive.

But we do not own time … it owns us.

More of Us Than Not

I think government of the people and for the people is coming back. I think that more of us than not are tired of the billionaires and trillionaires believing they can buy our votes with their money, and have politicians in their pocket.

I think more of us than not believe it is deeply wrong that our President and his family and friends are getting rich by selling access to power, selling pardons and trading geo-political policy for business interests.

I think more of us than not are disgusted with the efforts to change who we are, a nation built by immigrants dedicated to the advancement and prosperity of our children.  We will not be whitewashed in order to serve the power interests of exclusionist.

I think more of us than not are exhausted with the hijacking of religion by the crude, immoral and power hungry, who are confused by the lessons of the Good Samaritan and the admonishment to do to the least of us as we would to Christ.

I think more of us than not are ready to reclaim our democracy from the would be autocrats and oligarchs and their minions of incompetence… and we will show them how great our number is in a couple of weeks.

 

 

Fifty Years Ago

This guy walked into a hopping disco bar
crowded with a sea of youth wide and far
and saw a movie star with long golden hair
and eyes so blue he couldn’t help but stare.

But did she notice him?  Certainly not.
for their were many others much more hot
with long hair and bell bottom blue jeans
as it always was, at these nightclub scenes.

With false swagger he arrived just a little too late
as she left with another, and thus he assumed his fate
would be to be denied this one so beautiful and fair,
and wondered if he should try again, should he dare?

With courage and drink he did try again
and to his surprise she said yes, with a grin,
and on a crowded dance floor the romance did begin
and we’re still celebrating such a chance, such a win.

That two should meet and build a life
together as husband and wife.
A family born from the happenstance
of beauty at a disco dance.

And fifty years hence she is still the fairest of all
no matter the restaurant, bar or dance hall.
And he is just a boy who cannot help but stare
at the girl with blue eyes and golden hair.

 

 

The Nobel Peace Prize … Goes to:


image Courtesy of MS Magazine

Navi Pillay a distinguished judge with decades of service to ensuring international peace.  She is a prominent judge on the International Criminal Court (ICC), she served as UN High Commissioner for Human Rights from 2008 to 2014 and served on War Crimes Tribunals and UN Fact-Finding Panels.

Guess who criticized?

No you cannot possibly guess…

Trump… Yes… Trump said the award to Pillay forever discredited the prize. He should have won it over 8 times.

I kid you not…

Then for good measure he enacted sweeping sanctions against the ICC citing threats to American sovereignty.

… I’m convinced that Trump’s bible is Orwell’s 1984, for remember:

“War is peace.”

“Freedom is Slavery.”

“Ignorance is Strength.”

In its official announcement, the Norwegian Nobel Committee explicitly noted that the prize serves to remind the world that international and national rule of law underpins global peace.

 

 

Maybe We Should Wake Up?

If we permit ourselves
only an artificial world
and never really see the
trees or the horizon.

How would we know nature,
how will we appreciate
the skyline, and the forest
hiding among the trees?

What is a sunrise or a
sunset if only witnessed
in the posted pics  of others
and the colors of imagination?

How are we part of nature
if we eschew the wisdom it
screams at us every day
on the evening news?

Did we forget about
the warming of the earth
for the sake of profits
and lower taxes?

Wonder what will kill us first
the intelligence we created
or the wisdom of nature
we ignored?

 

 

Our Stories and Legend

Searching the past,
trying to understand
something beyond what
the history books tell.

The pictures of youth
with energy and vitality
and their words, not so
different than our own.

These people in faded
graying images, who
are still somehow alive
in stories and legend.

Will someday, our digital
images lost in space
be found and will anyone
learn our stories and legend?

Photo, from 1944, Sergeant and fighter pilot, Michael Vargo and his Nephew Michael Varga (Mickie)

AI Safety

I think there is a straightforward model for how to make sure AI continues to be developed as safely as possible. We can look at civil aviation industry which was being developed a century ago and how congress dealt with issues of safety at that time.  The FAA dates back to the Air Commerce Act of 1926 which was passed to regulate civil aviation after a period of barnstorming and mail flight accidents.

The early years of aviation was in all essence a  technology race.  Civil aviation initially had no rules, and it was being developed worldwide simultaneously.  Accident rates were too high in the early years of civil aviation. Instead of accepting the inherent dangers, congress did something about it.

The FAA evolved to be a federal agency that manages domestic safety of aviation equipment, pilots, maintenance, and all operations. It does so in direct partnership with companies. Contractors have their own FAA certified inspectors on staff, trained to ensure safety of all aspects of civil aviation. The FAA cooperates with equivalent bodies worldwide, including Europe (EASA), Canada (TCCA), China (CAAC) and others.  All are coordinated by an umbrella organization the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) which is a specialized agency of the United Nations.

Civil Aviation is not perfect, but for the most part civil aviation has proven to be incredibly safe, and yet there are still accidents, from which we learn and improve.

I believe AI development and deployment needs safety protocols and oversight, as well as, international cooperation. Companies, and the world will continue to benefit from the safe development and deployment of this technology, just as we all have benefited from safe development and deployment of Civil Aviation.  There will be accidents (as has already occurred) and we’ll have to learn from them and improve safety protocols. The people closest to the development know what needs to be done, but they need leadership and they need to be accountable and held accountable.

Yes, slow it down and make sure we understand what we are doing with this technology, but it is past time for Congress to act… and they have a great model to consider for how to approach the problem of AI Safety.  The FAA.

 

 

 

My Stories, Poetry, Thoughts of the day